AustLit logo
image of person or book cover 8016691786221346407.jpg
Image courtesy of publisher's website.
Issue Details: First known date: 2021... 2021 The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent
The material on this page is available to AustLit subscribers. If you are a subscriber or are from a subscribing organisation, please log in to gain full access. To explore options for subscribing to this unique teaching, research, and publishing resource for Australian culture and storytelling, please contact us or find out more.

AbstractHistoryArchive Description

'H. V. ‘Doc’ Evatt has long been obscured by Menzies’s broad shadow, as the Labor Opposition Leader through the prosperous and complacent 1950s. In this book, one of our finest writers and sharpest minds shows Evatt in his true light: the most brilliant Australian of his day. Inspiring, cosmopolitan and humane, Evatt was the forerunner of Keating and Kirby, believing that Australia could be more than quiet and comfortable – it could be an example to the world of a compassionate, just, progressive society.

'An acclaimed advocate, champion of modern art and state member for Balmain in the NSW Parliament, in 1930 Evatt became Australia’s youngest ever High Court judge, a regular dissenter from this arch conservative body as he tried to make the law responsive to the rapidly-changing modern world. Haigh traces one case in particular – that of the Chester family, who sued Waverley Council for the trauma of their young son's drowning in an unfenced ditch. Evatt’s legal brilliance, intellectual independence and personal empathy combined in a judgement regarded as the finest of its era, arguing that people’s inner lives were as valuable as their physical selves, and ought to be recognised as such by the law. The idea was far ahead of its time, but is now a fundamental legal principle.

'Evatt had been attuned to grief by losing two brothers in the First World War, which contributed both to his zest for life and his belief that the world should offer sanctuary to the afflicted. This conviction had long-lasting expression: as Australia’s only ever President of the UN General Assembly, Evatt was instrumental in the establishment of Israel. There are not many of whom it might be said that leading their party in federal politics was a step down, but Evatt was such a figure.

'The Brilliant Boy is a feat of remarkable historical perception, deep research and masterful storytelling. It confirms Gideon Haigh as not only our finest cricket writer, but one of our best writers of non-fiction. In painting this bigger picture of our past, The Brilliant Boy allows us to think differently about our present and future.' (Publication summary) 

Publication Details of Only Known VersionEarliest 2 Known Versions of

    • Cammeray, Cremorne - Mosman - Northbridge area, Sydney Northeastern Suburbs, Sydney, New South Wales,: Simon and Schuster Australia , 2021 .
      image of person or book cover 8016691786221346407.jpg
      Image courtesy of publisher's website.
      Extent: 240p.
      Note/s:
      • Published 7 July 2021

      ISBN: 9781760856113

Works about this Work

[Review] The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Paul Pearce , 2022 single work review
— Appears in: Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society , December vol. 108 no. 2 2022; (p. 255-256)

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography
Who Did He Think He Was? Patrick Mullins , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: Inside Story , July 2021;

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography

'Gideon Haigh’s new book throws fresh light on the remarkable H.V. Evatt'

Gideon Haigh : The Brilliant Boy: Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Bernard Whimpress , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: The Newtown Review of Books , December 2021;

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography

'Gideon Haigh has written a captivating account of the legal career of one of Australia’s most enthralling public figures, Herbert Vere Evatt, and a defining court case.'  (Introduction)

Doc’s Thirst for Justice Geoffrey Robertson , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: The Weekend Australian , 17 July 2021; (p. 17)

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography

'This is the story of two brilliant boys. Maxie Chester, who drowned in a deep ditch negligently left unfenced by Waverley Council and whose mother was traumatised by seeing his dead body brought to the surface. The other is Bert Evatt, genius son of a Maitland publican, who took all the honours the University of Sydney could bestow, became at 35 Australia’s youngest ever High Court judge and went on, at the end of the war, to help change the world. In 1939, Maxie’s miserable death intersected with “the Doc’s” intellectual power and compassion: his groundbreaking judgment opened the door to compensate all foreseeable victims of corporate carelessness.' (Introduction)

Destined for Brilliance Troy Bramston , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: The Weekend Australian , 10 July 2021; (p. 19)

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography
'Gideon Haigh releases a beautifully written, perceptive book about Doc Evatt as a younger man, writes TROY BRAMSTON' 
Another Country : A Bravura Act of Biographical Recovery Frank Bongiorno , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: Australian Book Review , July no. 433 2021; (p. 17-18)

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography
'To write of Herbert Vere Evatt (1894–1965) is to venture into a land where opinions are rarely held tentatively. While many aspects of his career have been controversial, his actions during the famous Split of 1955 arouse the most passionate criticism. Evatt is attacked, not only on the political right but frequently from within the Labor Party itself, for his alleged role in causing the catastrophic rupture that kept Labor out of office until 1972.' (Introduction)
Gideon Haigh The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Judith Brett , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: The Saturday Paper , 31 July-6 August 2021;

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography

'This book is about two brilliant boys. The first is the gifted and driven Bert or Doc Evatt. Of lower- middle-class origins, he went to Sydney’s Fort Street Boys’ High and on to law at Sydney University, winning prizes and scholarships all the way. Evatt shone at the Sydney bar in the early 1920s before entering the New South Wales parliament for Labor when Jack Lang was premier. Like his friend, Vere Gordon Childe, Evatt was a Labor intellectual – a difficult position in the party of the workers – but he established his credentials when he successfully prevented the Bruce government’s deportation of two union organisers, Tom Walsh and Jacob Johnson of the Seamen’s Union. Although born overseas, both were long-time Australian residents and Evatt argued successfully before the High Court that they were beyond the reach of the Immigration Act.' (Introduction)

Destined for Brilliance Troy Bramston , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: The Weekend Australian , 10 July 2021; (p. 19)

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography
'Gideon Haigh releases a beautifully written, perceptive book about Doc Evatt as a younger man, writes TROY BRAMSTON' 
Doc’s Thirst for Justice Geoffrey Robertson , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: The Weekend Australian , 17 July 2021; (p. 17)

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography

'This is the story of two brilliant boys. Maxie Chester, who drowned in a deep ditch negligently left unfenced by Waverley Council and whose mother was traumatised by seeing his dead body brought to the surface. The other is Bert Evatt, genius son of a Maitland publican, who took all the honours the University of Sydney could bestow, became at 35 Australia’s youngest ever High Court judge and went on, at the end of the war, to help change the world. In 1939, Maxie’s miserable death intersected with “the Doc’s” intellectual power and compassion: his groundbreaking judgment opened the door to compensate all foreseeable victims of corporate carelessness.' (Introduction)

Gideon Haigh : The Brilliant Boy: Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Bernard Whimpress , 2021 single work review
— Appears in: The Newtown Review of Books , December 2021;

— Review of The Brilliant Boy : Doc Evatt and the Great Australian Dissent Gideon Haigh , 2021 single work biography

'Gideon Haigh has written a captivating account of the legal career of one of Australia’s most enthralling public figures, Herbert Vere Evatt, and a defining court case.'  (Introduction)

Last amended 8 Dec 2021 11:36:43
X